Blue Tarp vs. Shrink-Wrapping a Roof: Which Is Better?

Wind damaged roof with shrink wrapping laid over to protect it.

Hurricane Ian was extremely devastated to SWFL and there are many roofs that still need to be repaired. When it comes to temporary roof protection, two popular options are blue tarps and shrink-wrapping. Both options provide a level of protection against the elements, but there are significant differences between the two. In this post, we will compare blue tarps and shrink-wrapping in terms of durability, cost, installation, and effectiveness to help you make an informed decision for your home.

1. Durability

  • Blue Tarps: Blue tarps are made of woven polyethylene and are water-resistant. However, they can be prone to tearing, especially in high winds. They may not hold up well over time and may need to be replaced frequently.

  • Shrink-Wrapping: Shrink-wrapping is made of a heavy-duty plastic material that is heated to shrink and fit tightly around the roof. It is more durable than blue tarps and can withstand harsh weather conditions, including high winds and heavy rains.

2. Cost

  • Blue Tarps: Blue tarps are relatively inexpensive and are widely available at most home improvement stores.

  • Shrink-Wrapping: Shrink-wrapping is more expensive than blue tarps, but it provides better protection and may be more cost-effective in the long run.

3. Installation

  • Blue Tarps: Installing a blue tarp can be a DIY job, but it may require several people to secure it properly. It is usually held in place with ropes or bungee cords.

  • Shrink-Wrapping: Shrink-wrapping requires professional installation. A trained technician will use a heat gun to shrink the plastic material around the roof, ensuring a tight fit.

4. Effectiveness

  • Blue Tarps: Blue tarps provide temporary protection against rain and debris. However, they may not hold up well in high winds and may allow water to seep through over time.

  • Shrink-Wrapping: Shrink-wrapping provides a watertight seal that protects against rain, wind, and debris. It is a more effective option for long-term protection.

Home Fixerz Construction Recommends:

While blue tarps are a popular and inexpensive option for temporary roof protection, they may not provide the level of durability and effectiveness needed for long-term protection. Shrink-wrapping, while more expensive, provides a watertight seal and can withstand harsh weather conditions. Ultimately, the best option will depend on your specific needs, budget, and the duration of time you need temporary roof protection. It is always recommended to consult with a professional before making a decision.

Previous
Previous

How to select the Right Contractor: A Comprehensive Guide.

Next
Next

Walk-In Showers vs. Bathtubs: Which is Right for Your Bathroom?